News
Article
Anchorage Daily News Editorial
Eagle parts ban is a dumb federal law
When statutes turn harmless actions by citizens into federal
crimes, it hurts respect for the law and
supplies anti-government ideologues with easy
ammunition to fight more justifiable measures. A
case in point: It is illegal for anyone in
Alaska to keep an eagle feather that has fallen
naturally to the ground. Federal law prohibits
anyone from possessing any eagle part, unless it
comes from the federally run eagle repository in
the Lower 48.
That restriction is particularly galling to Alaska Natives. Eagle
feathers are widely used in traditional Native
ceremonies and artwork. Even though bald eagles
in Alaska are not and never have been
endangered, and even though they gather by the
hundreds and even thousands in some locations,
anyone who might scoop up a few feathers that
have fallen to the Earth risks an unpleasant
visit from the feds.
A Juneau artist learned that lesson last year. Mark Horn was
selling artwork with eagle feathers he had
collected. The feds investigated and confiscated
the artwork.
In Alaska, the federal restrictions on gathering loose eagle
feathers inflict a pointless bureaucratic hassle
on people who make legitimate cultural use of
eagle feathers. It's disrespectful to Alaska
Native cultures to require federal permission
for collecting such an abundant and culturally
important natural object.
Two Juneau Native groups last month wrote to the feds, protesting
the restrictions. A similar complaint was
expressed in a resolution recently passed by the
Alaska Native Brotherhood and the Southeast
Alaska Native Summit.
The Southeast Natives are not asking for permission to kill
eagles. They are merely asking for some
commonsense flexibility in a ridiculously
restrictive law. In Alaska, at least, there is
no harm in letting Natives use naturally
collected eagle feathers in traditional
ceremonies and crafts.
elizabeth.bluemink@juneauempire.com.
|